Skip to content
Lemnigent

Should my inbox sort itself?

Eight quick questions about the messages you get. You get back the hours the sorting costs you, the categories nobody owns, and the ones that must never be answered without a person.

The problem this settles

The inbox is not full of hard questions. It is full of easy ones mixed in with a few that matter, and the cost is the sorting: reading each one to work out whose it is, whether it is urgent, and whether it can wait. Nobody counts that time because it never looks like work, it looks like ten seconds, several hundred times a week.

So the usual request is to have something answer the mail, which is the wrong half of the job. Sorting is where the hours are and where software is reliable, because recognising what a message is about is a much easier problem than knowing what is true about your business. Replying is where it goes wrong, and it goes wrong on exactly the messages that cost you most: a refund, an invoice, a delivery date, anything that commits you to something.

This check separates the two. It counts the hours going into sorting from your own volume and your own handling time, names the categories nobody owns, ranks what to route first, and lists what must never be answered without a person. It will also tell you when the honest answer is that your volume does not justify the rules, or that the real problem is that four categories have no owner and a folder will not fix it.

  1. Your inbox
  2. Your answer
  3. Your rules

Question 1 of 8

What does the business do?

A few words is plenty.

It goes into the prompt you run yourself. It stays in your browser and never reaches us.

How to use it

  1. 1Answer eight questionsQuick picks about where messages arrive, how many a week, what they are about, how long one takes just to sort, and whether every kind has somebody who deals with it. One short line about the business. Two minutes.
  2. 2Run the prompt in your own ChatGPTThe page writes the prompt and opens ChatGPT with it already sent. A free account is fine, and Claude or Gemini work too. You never paste a message, an address or a mailbox anywhere, and nothing comes to us.
  3. 3Bring the answer backCopy the code block at the end of its reply and paste it back on the page. Ctrl+V anywhere works. The page reads it and scores it against the rubric published here.
  4. 4Read the verdict and take the reportYou get the hours going into sorting, the categories to route first, the ones with no owner, and the list that must never be answered automatically. The report is on the page in full. If you want the image file to keep or forward, that is where we ask for an email.

How the score works

This score is ours, not an industry standard. It is the same seven things we check before building anyone's triage: does every category have an owner, does most of what arrives repeat, can software reach where it lands, is there enough of it to be worth the rules, is anything with money or a promise fenced off from automatic replies, does a promised response time have something watching the clock, and are the answers written down. We score sorting and replying separately on purpose, because almost everybody wants the second and almost everybody should buy the first. It is published here so you can disagree with it.

  • 20Every category has somebody who deals with it
  • 20Most of what arrives is a handful of things, over and over
  • 15The messages arrive somewhere software can reach
  • 15There is enough of it to be worth the rules
  • 15Nothing with money or a promise in it can be answered on its own
  • 10A promise has something watching the clock
  • 5The answers exist somewhere, for later

Questions

What is email triage, in plain words?

Deciding what a message is about and who should deal with it, before anybody answers it. Most people do it by reading everything in order, which is why a full inbox feels like work before any work has happened. Triage is the part that can be written as rules, because you are already applying rules, just in your head and one message at a time.

Should the software reply, or only sort?

Sort first, and probably only sort for a good while. Recognising what a message is about is a much easier problem than knowing what is true about your business today, and the sorting is where the hours are. Replying is where it goes wrong, and it goes wrong hardest on the messages about money, dates and refunds, which are exactly the ones a customer remembers.

How many hours does sorting actually cost?

Multiply the messages you get by the time it takes to decide where one goes. This check does it from your own two numbers rather than an industry figure, because the answer varies by more than ten times between a shop and a professional services firm. The point of doing the arithmetic is that the total is usually several times what anybody guessed.

Do you see my answers or any of my messages?

No. The questions, the prompt and the scoring all run in your browser. You are never asked for a message, an address or access to a mailbox. Nothing is sent anywhere unless you fill in the form at the end, and that form shows you the exact note before it goes.

Do I need a paid ChatGPT account?

No. A free account works, and so does Claude or Gemini. The prompt asks for a code block at the end of the reply, which all three can do.

Who is this not for?

If you get under about fifty messages a week, the sorting is annoying rather than expensive and a set of rules is work to maintain. The check will say so. It is also not for an inbox where every message is genuinely different, because there is nothing there to recognise.

What about the messages that need a person?

They still need a person, and the routing's job is to get them there faster with the context attached. The best outcome is not fewer human replies, it is that every human reply starts with somebody who already knows what it is about and has the account open.

How long does it take, and what do I get?

Eight questions, one prompt and one paste. You get the hours going into sorting, your categories ranked by what they cost, the ones with no owner, a never-auto-answer list, and the first routing rule drawn out.

What if the answer is that I should not automate it?

Then you have saved a project, and the page tells you which of the two real reasons it is: not enough volume to pay back the rules, or categories with nobody behind them. The second one is the common one, and a folder makes it worse rather than better.

Can this work with a shared mailbox rather than a helpdesk?

Yes, and a shared mailbox is the easier starting point. What does not work is routing out of somebody's personal mailbox, because the only way to do it is to read their mail. If the work currently arrives there, moving it to one shared address is the first job and it is worth doing whether or not anything gets automated afterwards.

Tell us what you are building.

Thirty minutes, free, with the people who would do the work.

Book a call